The following is the Introduction from
"Stories of Men, Meaning and Prayer"
by Jeffrey Duvall
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is possible, and perhaps likely, that the very source of human
consciousness arose from a prayer, a communication with something
greater. It may have gone something like this: an ancient man or
woman has suffered a great loss, unable to place it or make sense of
it, angry, desperate, frightened and trembling next to a small fire,
no longer satisfied with the inherently timeless response of its
animal mind, turns deep-set eyes toward the boundless night sky and
asks that first halting human question: What...meaning...this? He
runs the sharp edge of the bone scraper, given him by his
grandfather, against the soft flesh of his palm, sees the old man
demonstrating to him as a boy the uses of the tool, telling him
stories of the hunt and the rituals of preparation, and all of this
has brought him to this place, to this question of meaning.I
would not presume to enter this storm of human nature, this
turbulent, deafening flood of hope and grief and mystery, and come
out with answers. Thousands of theologians, philosophers and mystics
have entered these waters with scholarship and discipline far
greater than my own. These great masters have returned from the
tempest with some picture of the storm, tried to place it in some
objective form. Their contributions are of a kind much different
from what I offer.
Mine is more along the lines of a shipwreck survivor, in awe of
what he has witnessed and experienced, who combs the shores in
search of remnants, bits and pieces of cargo, the leg of a chair,
one edge of a picture frame, a wooden spoon, the hairs in a broken
brush, the page of a journal, soggy and washed clean of ink, a
feather from a hat, one broken shard of an old man's spectacles.
From these relics of my own experience, I have accumulated a story
about prayer. It is not a matter of interest to me that it be fact,
that it stand up under logical scrutiny. It's possible that none of
it is right. In the event that any of my scavenging touches you or
provides something of value in your life, all the better. And should
it be the opposite, that may be even more important. Often my
deepest lessons have come from receiving what I don't want. I was
told by many a guide and teacher to grasp from others what resonates
for me and to let go what doesn't resonate. I invite you to do the
same.
My story is the harvest from fifteen years of working with men in
ritual settings. I have traveled to many places and sat in circles
with thousands of people from all walks of life. What I have
observed during this time is that men are hungry. I am hungry. We
all have different tastes, and so what satisfies one man may hold no
zest for another. Blessed be. Still, we share in common the hunger
for meaning, fulfillment, a feeling of purpose, the knowledge that
our lives matter. I've heard it said that God exists in the
yearning. Maybe so. I don't know any more about this than anyone
else. And I'm not interested in the intellectual debate about which
approach to prayer is better than another. I don't want to leverage
my view against another faith. Enough wars have been fought over
such matters to discourage me from inciting conflict on the subject
of prayer. Spiritual dead ends that leave us no alternative but to
fight seem to contradict the soul's evolution. Rather, I seek ways
to bring us together for the inquiry.
I desire to know: What is your path? Do you care for yourself,
respect and hold yourself in enough love to find your personal path
of heart? This is what matters to me. I don't care if it means
sitting in church on Sundays, or sitting in meditation or a sweat
lodge or a synagogue, mosque, cave or coven. We don't need to fight
savagely about these things. The people and the earth have been
devastated enough. Still, it is imperative that we continue the
dialogue, while we keep our strong opinions held in loose gloves. It
is possible to have fruitful, rewarding interactions without ever
deciding one way is better or more correct than another.
One place of worship is not better than another. Mine is not the
way. We need all the ways, all the approaches. In my travels, I have
never found that one spiritual practice had more of a connection to
meaning, spirit, ancestors and the soul than another. The beauty of
the tundra comes from the linkage of many small systems. Some taking
over others. Some able to hold on to only the harshest outcroppings
of rock. Each interacting with and enriching the whole landscape,
and thus each other. Hunters and the hunted. Do you agree that the
moose, at times, needs the wolf to eat it?
There was a man once, a well respected elder in the peace
movement, who was interviewed about his life. The interviewer
suggested that he must feel good about his position as a pioneer in
the peace movement, someone whom so many people had followed and
emulated. He said, "No, not at all, I would have failed in my vision
if anybody followed in my footsteps." His point was that for peace
to work, individuals have to make it their own. Whatever the
practice, the goal or desire, individuals are responsible and have
the greatest impact by relating from their centers.
As difficult as it is at times, I mostly prefer to be in
ceremonial and prayer circles with people who are not like minded.
These times in which we live draw us to the difficult relationships
with those we may dispute. Our souls call out for us to find ways to
communicate and honor each other - at least to make the attempt a
practice, and be willing to accept the outcome. In this way, our
lives can enjoy a similar richness of diversity as that embodied by
the tundra. Joseph Campbell told the story of his invitation to a
prestigious conference on the state of human culture and
consciousness in the late 20th Century. He was to speak to a group
of the world's best minds. Campbell had recently quit his faculty
post at a respected French university when he realized all he had
done in his academic career was memorize other people's ideas and
regurgitate them correctly. He didn't know what he thought, how his
studies related to - as he would later become famous for saying -
"follow your bliss." And so he came to this conference, prepared to
speak about such matters, tingling with an intuition he was being
set up.
He spoke the passion of his newfound awakening and awaited the
response. The assembled experts shredded him, and it began to look
as if he, invited to this important international conference, was a
fool. The facilitator invited him to rebut. Campbell said an old
South American shaman once told him that when you're climbing a
steep mountain - and that's what we're doing here, he emphasized -
and a bird defecates on your head, do not release your grip to wipe
it off! In other words, we have to remember what we're here for. We
have to cultivate an inner strength, resources and allies, so we
feel strong enough to engage at any level, so that when we are
challenged, we have alternatives more noble than blind reprisal. It
is the desperate man who responds to difficulty with violence, and
furthers the stereotype that all men are violent. I do not believe
this, even though we are born with the ability to kill - all of us,
man, woman, child.
These capacities are native to the human condition and require
attention, the skill of a disciplined heart. This is especially true
for men, given recent discoveries of male brain structure. The
findings indicate that evolution has tailored the brains of men to
respond aggressively to the world around them. The attribute was
continued, through natural selection, because it often made the
difference in survival of the people. Given this as a natural
propensity, it makes sense to work with it as a necessary and
valuable force that can be embraced and refined in service of
responsible living. A fundamental component of this refinement is to
address soul hunger. This, I have found, leads to maturity. A man's
trustworthiness compares to his knowledge of the inner terrain, the
crooked bones and quagmires of our ancestors.
I had the pleasure of working with a 100-year-old healer in
Chicago I knew as Dr. Herman. He was an incredibly well-traveled
man, a friend of Mahatma Gandhi, and in whose presence I felt
humble. On our first acquaintance, he asked me if I believe in God.
Oh no, I thought, here we go. I knew he was a devout Christian. I'm
not going to believe in the right God, I thought, and he's going to
reject and shame me. I told him I believe in nature. "Good," he
said, "as long as you believe." That's what mattered to him. That's
what he needed to know to take me as a student. I would offer the
same question to you. What do you believe in? What do you have faith
in? Upon what do you draw upon in hard times? To what do you express
gratitude in good times? And are you capable of gratitude and growth
from the hard times? Where is it in your life that you contact the
sacred? This is how poet Mary Oliver works with these same
questions:
I don't know exactly what prayer is.
I do know how to pay attention, how to fall down
into the grass, how to kneel down in the grass,
how to be idle and blessed, how to stroll through the fields,
which is what I have been doing all day.
Tell me, what else should I have done?
Doesn't everything die at last, and too soon?
Tell me, what is it you plan to do
with your one wild and precious life? 1
I do not raise these questions as abstract points for discussion. To
me, there is urgency in this. The children cry out for their elders
to know this terrain and to guide them into it. How many prisons are
we going to construct in order to lock away the dangerous,
anti-social young men lost in Dante's dark woods and with no beacon?
What does it say about us as a culture that we have little ability
to relate to the wild aggression of our adolescent men? When will we
stop lying to ourselves and our children about who we really are and
learn to look our sons and daughters in the eyes and tell them we
know they have the power to kill, that we know this destructive
tapestry within ourselves, and we know of alternatives? Michael
Meade has said the soul is like iron that needs to be hammered out
in life. As adults we must learn about this hammering, practice it
and utilize our life's experience as the blows that pound out our
inner dimension, and become aware of what stops us from knowing this
natural and necessary process. Rainer Marie Rilke speaks about such
things in his Letters to a Young Poet:
...and I want to beg you, as much as I can, to be patient toward
all that is unresolved in your heart and try to love the questions
themselves, like locked rooms and like books written in a very
foreign tongue. Do not now seek the answers, that cannot be given
you because you would not be able to live them. And the point is to
live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then
gradually, without noticing it, live along some distant day into the
answer. 2
Victor Frankl describes his experience standing before a firing
squad, watching the soldiers enact the protocol and ritual of
execution, and at the final moment, the only thing remaining the
command to "fire!", a bomb drops behind them, and the soldiers
scatter and his life is saved. In that moment, the moment just
before death, Frankl found the deepest serenity of his life. He
describes the moment in his book Man's Search for Meaning:
In a position of utter desolation, when man cannot express himself
in a positive action, when his only achievement may consist in
enduring his suffering in the right way - in an honorable way - in
such a position man can, through loving contemplation of the image
he carries of his beloved, achieve fulfillment. 3
All too often in our time, the moments of utter desolation are
responded to with violence, either on ourselves or on others. Young
people and adults alike recoil from difficulty and suffering because
they do not know, or have never been around somebody who knows, the
fulfillment and grace described by Victor Frankl. I don't want to
set people's agendas for how they approach these dark and
frightening places within themselves. My interest is to point out
the depth of human potential for inspired living. I only hope, in
some small way, to call people to the threshold, to perhaps
highlight the gateway, provide some encouragement, stories and bits
and pieces of gathered inspiration that may serve as a torch to
light the way at least for a short distance, and maybe, if fortune
smiles, to help my brothers and sisters find the sanctuary within
themselves that houses their faith. This alone will carry them
forward when my small torch burns out.
I have been interested for many years in various healing
practices and shamanic rituals, known by my ancestors and healers
around the world. A common truth I have found among them all is that
without faith, little can come into us that sustains the heart, soul
and community. We all have the capacity to block out what we need so
dearly by our own skepticism and doubt. So many of us have been
subjected to oppressive approaches to faith that we have learned not
to trust and have been left with so little. Men in particular have
been blamed for the ills of the world and have learned to distrust
each other, themselves and their gods. This type of training for men
in our culture fractures our connections in the continuum of
existence. In the ways that we are separated from our own greatness,
the potential of our godliness, our divinity, there is the
possibility of blindly harming others, the spirit of nature, the
delicate balance of evolution and growth in our souls and that of
the community. The path of blame and scorn only drives the wedge
deeper into a man's heart.
The blind finger pointing does not make men stronger or more
loving or more trustworthy. Rather, why not all of us own the
mistakes of our heritage? Why not all of us embrace the tragedies
our people lived through and in so doing sanctify the journey and
pledge to do better ourselves? Prayer can help with this. I'm
interested in helping people find something, anything, that works
for them and gives them access to the universal language of prayer,
its one face with many faces. I'm interested in the simple act of
prayer, of listening, of attention to our own indigenous wisdom, to
the exploration and continuance of what the human soul already
knows, to the practice of attending the nonlinear truths as guiding
forces and to challenge the dominant, logical, linear- based systems
and practicalities. And to know the difference.
I remember an Episcopal bishop who noticed me waiting on tables
in Marquette, Michigan, and invited me to his home. He brought me to
this intimidating mansion the church provided and into a library
stacked from floor to ceiling with volumes of books. He pointed to
them and told me he didn't need any of these books, that none of
them brought him any closer to God - outer or the inner, and perhaps
more germane, the lack of separation between the two. And then he
reached up and pulled one small volume, and handed it to me. "But
this one," he said, "this is the one of them all." And he gave me
that book, The Lives of a Cell, 4 by Lewis Thomas. I was shocked.
Me, a waiter, a lowly peasant, but this high holy man in the church
saw me. He saw me. And he became a mentor and guide and inspired me
to find my own faith, to simply learn to believe in myself. He knew
that the important thing was not in any particular dogma, but in the
personal inspiration.
This is a serious issue for me. Too many times have I heard
stories of men shamed and oppressed by autocratic religious
approaches. I myself come from the Catholic faith. I am still
transported by the smell of frankincense and ringing bells to my
time as an altar boy. To this day I have a deep respect and love for
the church. Still, I see in it the potential to shut down the
creative expression of the individual soul. All doctrines have a
shadow - as my words most surely do as well - and in the
unacknowledged shadow lies the potential for abuse. To me, the
abusiveness comes from power and hierarchy that is set up as
superior to the individual and discounts and in some cases condemns
our instinctive knowing. The faithful either bow to this power or
risk exile and even annihilation. Hawthorne's Scarlet Letter speaks
to this, but history has no shortage of examples, from the Spanish
Inquisition to the Salem witch trials, to the modern cults of Branch
Davidians and the Jonestown massacre. These are cases in which logic
and intellect and the rigid human constructs of political expediency
crush the deeper truths each of us holds. I believe that our warm
hearts know our soul's lineage. Our ancestors' lives, their
experience, let's call it wisdom, is our very blood's knowing. I
like the way the Lakota medicine man Frank Fools Crow put it in the
book by Thomas E. Mails when describing the conversion of his people
to Christianity:
We Sioux prayed to Wakan-Tanka personally and constantly. We even
thanked him for the lessons that hardship taught us... So both the
good times and the bad times taught us valuable lessons about life
and about daily prayer. What confused me most was the fact that the
churches had books with prayers already written in them by white
people who had lived a long time ago, that these were the only ones
we Indians were to say as members and even then only inside the
building that was called the church. I couldn't figure out how
prayers like that could fit our daily needs. They weren't personal
enough. 5
Didn't the Lakota people have a sophisticated spiritual tradition
just as vital, just as valid and worthy as that of the European
settlers? How easy would it have been to find a common ground had
the new immigrants to the Great Plains learned that the Lakota
people believed in a trinity of father, son and holy spirit very
similar to theirs? That said, it should be noted Fools Crow was a
practicing Roman Catholic his entire life, went to church regularly
and took communion, yet he continued to practice the traditional
Lakota healing ceremonies of sweat lodge and Yuwipi. How did he
reconcile these apparently contradictory approaches? This is what
I'm trying to get at. I don't want to blame Christianity or set up
another us-and-them polarity. Any faith, any practice, any method
can become oppressive and harmful. Some of the New Age ideals are
terribly restrictive in my judgment. It's easy enough to go astray.
What I'm hoping for is a coming together, a free and open dialogue
based on mutual respect. I envision an expansive practice of ritual,
a rich, diverse life of prayer, openness for healing, responsible
actions toward the earth, each other and our inner selves. I believe
the earth and our ancestors call us to this. With what seems to be
less and less connection with solitude and introspective practices,
and a world more and more degraded, this call I speak of here,
expressed by many an elder, demands to be heard.
In prayer, we can show we are listening. Prayer can serve as a
gateway to the dimension between night and day, between life and
death. It can and does serve us in the quest for peace, but we have
to slow down long enough and make room in ourselves for it to enter.
Again, the ways to do this are too many to count. Larry Dossey 6 has
exhaustively researched the phenomena of prayer. He found that the
context did not matter. The style, method, words - none of it seemed
to affect the outcome. The act itself, the sincerity and intention,
were the common factors in effective prayer. When I say effective,
I'm not talking about getting results, in the concrete sense of
asking for something and receiving it directly. The power of prayer
is not about taking away the pain of the world. To me it's about
personal evolution connected to all that has been and will be, about
being able to hear and receive the blessings and support already
waiting to be given. An elder at Spirit Camp, a men's retreat held
in the ceremonial hands of ritual and prayer, once said that ritual
becomes belief. What you pray for, you become. There's that old
prayer adage, "Be careful what you ask for." This may appear trite,
but its simple message calls us to the mystery of prayer. I've
spoken with hundreds, perhaps thousands of men, about prayer and
ritual, participated in ceremony with them, married and buried them,
and almost to a man they concede an inability to control the
outcome. To let oneself be guided, to trust and have faith in one's
own divine grace is one of the great gifts of prayer. And in such
surrender comes unimaginable possibility, the room and space inside
for personal growth and evolution. The greatly respected therapist
Milton Ericson knew about this. He let the patient structure the
treatment and said, "I always trust my unconscious." He let himself
be guided by something beyond his ordinary awareness. All of us can
tap into this resource, and in so doing, serve ourselves and our
communities in simple, profound ways.
I invite you to join me on this exploration of prayer, to take
any bits or parts that serve you on your journey, and pay attention
and trust your own sense of what doesn't fit for you. As I said
before, I don't presume to have answers about this subject, just
some experience, some stories, some gathered artifacts that, under
ideal circumstances, may provide a little guidance, a signpost or
two as to some possible topography. Our elders and nature teach us
that life's main chore is to plumb the depths of our full potential
in heart, soul and meaning. Each of us has our distinct way of
being, healing, growing and expressing beauty. I offer this book as
a prayer, as a gratitude to my ancestors, with the hope that it can
serve and contribute to the richness of life. I am reminded of the
gift given us by Sir Laurens van der Post in his documentaries on
the Bushmen of the Kalahari 7. After a long search for an active,
functioning Bushmen clan, van der Post and his colleagues finally
came upon a solitary, traditional Bushman in the desert. The guide,
who came from a tribe of Bushmen no longer living the nomadic life,
nonetheless knew the native tongue and spoke the words to his
nomadic brother that caused him to run toward him as if something
terrible had happened. When asked what he said, the guide told van
der Post he had said to his brother he was hungry. Sir Laurens
thought it remarkable that the wild and free Bushman would respond
to a call of hunger with such urgency. The guide informed him he had
told his brother he had "the big hunger," the one that is beyond the
stomach's demand for food, but comes from the heart's cry for
meaning. This made perfect sense to van der Post, and he later said,
"...once what you are living and what you are doing has for you
meaning, it is irrelevant whether you are happy or unhappy. You are
content. You're not alone in your spirit. You belong." And so I
offer this book as a possible tool in finding your belonging in the
beauty of your soul. Bless the big hunger in all of us, and bless
the heart's knowing of just how urgent the hunger is, and may it be
so that when we recognize the big hunger in ourselves, in our
brothers, sisters and children, we run to it and do not shy from it
or recoil but run to it and find some way to soothe it, that we
arrive together at the many gates of initiation, our growing into
who we are, a little bit hungry.
It is helpful, I find, to come into our passages with a belly
less than full. It seems to help us notice the unexpected blessings,
and necessary challenges, life brings to us. A hungry heart and soul
notices the basic simple truths coming to us from our ancestors,
rendered in life's meaning. It is normal, and often less impressive,
to know the natural power of kindness, compassion and love toward
ourselves and others. I offer this wayfarer's story as inspiration
to find our purpose and let it be our guide. My offering, and
prayer, is that we can be active in our families, communities, and
be the makers of human evolution. I ask that we not surrender to the
many reasons and forces in our culture, in our psyches, that confuse
our own integrity. May this small gift be a tribute to our ancestors
and to all of nature, past, present and future. In this spirit I
dedicate these simple thoughts.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Oliver, Mary. New And Selected Poems (Boston, Beacon Press,
1992).
2. Rilke, Rainer Marie. Letters to a Young Poet (New York, W.W.
Norton & Company Inc., 1934).
3. Frankl, Viktor E. Man's Search for Meaning (New York, Pocket
Books, 1959, 1963).
4. Thomas, Lewis. The Lives of a Cell: Notes of a Biology Watcher
(New York, Bantam Books, 1974).
5. Mails, Thomas E. Fools Crow (Lincoln, Bison Book, 1979, 1990).
6. Dossey, Larry, M.D. Healing Words, The Power Of Prayer And The
Practice Of Medicine (New York, HarperCollins, 1993).
7. Van Der Post, Laurens. The Heart of the Hunter: Customs and Myths
of the African Bushmen (san Diego, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1961).
|